How Good Are Your Manager/Employee Check-ins?

kara • January 22, 2024

One-on-one touch points are the meetings that managers and employees have with each other on a regular or semi-regular basis. In our experience, at most organizations, just having the meeting at all is considered success, but our point of view is that these one-on-one touch points are one of the most powerful mechanisms through which managers can engage and inspire their employees. That means, we care about optimizing these touch points.


In our mind, optimized manager/employee check-ins are meaningful conversations through which managers and their employees develop authentic connection and trust. We know from our coaching conversations that this isn’t always the case. Managers are often overextended, underprepared, or unable to focus their full attention during the touch points.


For many of the leaders we coach, they’re doing the best they can as their company deals with massive organizational instability and change. There are some layoffs, and then all of a sudden they’re managing (what feels like) 100 people when they used to manage 5. It’s hard for employees to get focused and dedicated attention from their managers, and even harder for those same employees to give their managers feedback, especially if the check-ins are sporadic and sub-optimized.



Since check-ins are so important, we wanted to make sure managers are empowered with a diagnostic tool to evaluate the quality of the one-on-one conversations they’re having with the employees. Managers can complete the diagnostic to evaluate how well they’re doing in leading these critical meetings.



What do you notice about your answers? There are likely some things you’re already doing well as well as areas of improvement. Do an experiment and change one thing up differently for your next check-in.

Share this article

Recent Posts

By Stephanie Judd July 5, 2026
When we tell people that Wolf & Heron doesn't use slides in its in-person workshops, they often respond with an excited, “I love that! How refreshing!” That reaction is telling. Nobody says "that's weird." They are instantly relieved, relaxed and excited. They say refreshing — which means somewhere, on some level, they already know that slides aren't working the way they're supposed to. And in fact, workshops or presentations that rely on slides often make us sleepy. Here's the science behind why.
By Stephanie Judd June 15, 2026
Stephanie was coaching Lauren who, by every measure, had the change under control. She was leading her organization through a significant shift, managing multiple moving pieces at once. She communicated clearly. She had systems in place. Her team was executing. When Stephanie checked in with her, she said she felt on top of it. Then she showed up to a coaching conversation completely distraught. One of her employees had quit. The reason given: burnout. This was the person she had been most relying on to carry the weight of the change, someone who had been performing flawlessly and showing up fully to every task. What Lauren hadn't seen was what was happening underneath: the cumulative weight of what this employee had been quietly absorbing, week after week, until it finally pushed her to a breaking point. 
By Stephanie Judd June 1, 2026
A few weeks ago, Stephanie got on a call with a client she's been coaching for several months. This client, a public health leader who had spent years building a program she believed in, was in tears.  The list of what she was navigating was almost hard to say out loud: federal funding for her department was evaporating. Public trust in the field she'd devoted her career to had cratered in the years since COVID. There was an active measles outbreak demanding her team's around-the-clock attention. The strategic plan she'd helped design was effectively on hold. And in the same week, both her boss and her most trusted employee had resigned, with a hiring freeze in place that meant no one would be coming to help.
By Stephanie Judd May 18, 2026
“Read the room” is common advice in professional settings, especially when people are preparing for high-stakes meetings or working with senior stakeholders. What people usually mean is that they want you to: navigate different audiences well show up professionally and handle complex real-time dynamics with confidence. Most people are told they need to read the room, but the more critical skill is what you do next and how you adapt in the moment when things don’t go as expected.  “Reading the room” is actually much more about how you lead in the moment. As an influential communicator, you must be willing to check in with the group rather than move on. Then, try something different to re-engage people and move the discussion forward.
Show More