How to Give Constructive Feedback

September 9, 2024
Woman showing a document to a man at a table, both smiling, with coffee, laptop, and tablet.

Recently, Stephanie and Kara gave some post-workshop coaching to a manager in crisis. He stayed on after our Powerful Questions OneHour Workshop because he was experiencing a particular issue with an employee and couldn’t see a way through it.


“Bob, comes to me for our check-ins with nothing but problems, and he asks me for the solutions. It’s so frustrating. I don’t get it. All my other employees come to me with ideas or solutions and we can collaborate from there. I don’t know how to get him out of his mindset that it’s my job to do all the creative problem-solving.” This wasn’t the first time we heard from a manager about an issue like this. From a managers pov, there are employees who complain all the time, employees who seem distracted, employees who are frustrated with the powers that be, employees that for whatever reason don’t seem to be performing up to expectations… and managers everywhere who don’t know how to address the attitude or behavioral issue with their employees.


But it’s no wonder! This is tough for many managers to navigate, regardless of the particular issue. Once a manager has mustered up the willingness to prepare for and deliver feedback, it requires attention, time and curiosity to work through. For many managers, these difficult conversations cause additional mental load because they are accompanied by fear and anxiety.


Instead of avoiding those conversations, managers should take the time to think through the issue, clarify their thoughts about what’s going on, and then develop a plan for what to do next. The good thing is that there doesn’t have to be a clear solution to the problem, just a plan for how to find it.

We can do the work of getting you there on a coaching call. But if you don’t have access to a coach, here are a few things to consider.


Dos... 


  • Be clear and specific
  • Assume positive intent
  • Be considerate of the employee’s emotional experience
  • Focus on behaviors, not personalities
  • Ask WHEN, WHERE, HOW, and WHAT questions 
  • Come up with next steps together


...and Don’ts 


  • Make assumptions
  • Focus on winning or being right
  • Get defensive
  • Bring in your emotional baggage
  • Ask WHY or closed yes/ no questions


With that in mind, if you are a manager with any type of problem employee, schedule yourself 30 minutes, download this reflection worksheet. By the time you’ve completed the worksheet, you will have processed your own feelings, identified what’s important, and come up with a plan to have a feedback conversation with your employee.

Summary of Takeaways

Giving feedback is often accompanied by anxiety and mental load, leading many managers to avoid it altogether. However, avoiding these conversations only prolongs the issue. To deliver feedback effectively, shift your focus from "being right" to "collaborative growth":


  1. Focus on Behaviors, Not Personalities: Effective feedback is clear and specific. Instead of critiquing who an employee is, address the specific actions or habits that need to change.
  2. Assume Positive Intent: Approaching the conversation with curiosity and empathy reduces defensiveness. Consider the employee’s emotional experience and acknowledge that there might be factors you haven't considered.
  3. Ask "How" and "What" Instead of "Why": Questions starting with "Why" can feel accusatory. Use open-ended questions like "What would help you feel more empowered to solve this?" to encourage reflection and ownership.
  4. Avoid Assumptions and Baggage: Don't let your own past frustrations or emotional baggage cloud the feedback. Stay grounded in the current observation and be wary of making assumptions about the employee’s motivations.
  5. Plan the "Next Steps" Together: You don’t need to have all the answers. The goal of the conversation is to develop a plan for finding a solution together, ensuring both parties are committed to the outcome.



The Bottom Line: Feedback shouldn't be a one-way street. By preparing with intentionality and shifting from a "director" to a "coach" role, you turn a difficult conversation into a strategic opportunity for development.

Share this article

Recent Posts

Nine illustrated video call participants in colorful tiles with reaction icons along the bottom
By Kara Davidson • November 2, 2026
On video, if you’re not talking, you may just disappear. How to build virtual presence that’s still you, with real examples from our coaching.
Stephanie Judd interview in The Executive Insight
November 2, 2026
Wolf & Heron co-founder Stephanie Judd talks with The Executive Insight about slide-free training, surviving COVID, and closing the gap between agreement and action.
By Stephanie Judd • October 19, 2026
The first time Stephanie watched Damien work, he had a Palm Pilot in each hand, an earbud in each ear, and apparently half his brain listening to two calls simultaneously. (Yes, that Palm Pilot reference ages Stephanie. She’s aware.) Damien seemed to be everywhere at once, always with something to give. He was also her skip-level boss. His kids were teenagers, and Stephanie was closer in age to them than she was to him. In her first job out of college, he both impressed and terrified her.  So when Stephanie was sent to Ithaca, NY on a recruiting trip to Cornell with Damien, her nerves took over. She saw this two-day trip as an amazing opportunity to build a relationship with him, and she wanted to make sure to impress him with her easy competence and magnanimity. Yes, always the overachiever, Stephanie had a clear vision of how the trip was supposed to go.
By Kara Davidson • October 5, 2026
It's never been more important to be yourself. Kara's brother learned this while hiring for his company. He was eight interviews into a search for a new position at this company, and every one of them wasn’t who they said they were on their resume. Some invented their experience. Others leaned so hard on AI that he couldn't find the actual person behind the answers. He was aggravated trying to figure out what was real and what wasn’t. All he knew for sure was that he couldn’t trust his own read, so he handed the search to a recruiter. That's what happens when people can't tell what's real. They get suspicious of everyone. And when one thing about someone seems off, we doubt the whole person: the experience, the credentials, the firm handshake.
Show More